Should children have weight loss surgery?

This month, there has been a lot of talk about whether or not it would be a healthy option for obese children to have bariatric surgeries.

It seems like a very complicated topic as the alarmingly high number of obese children in America is a strong indicator of the alarmingly high rate of obesity amongst all of the people in our country.

I do not yet have children and so I am not sure how I would feel if I were to have a child who was obese, knowing the potential health risks they have as a result of their obesity, if I would turn to a surgery like this, which also has very serious risks.

Doctors say there are many risks to subjecting a child in particular to this type of surgery, and that there is still so much that is unknown about obese children, leading them to discourage parents from turning to surgery as the first option when their child is obese.

It seems practical to me that the first option-for a child or an adult-should be to try and make a major lifestyle overhaul, changing the entire way you think about food, consume food, and exercise, before turning to any medical procedure that has significant risks.

But when it comes to children, I feel even moreso that we should consider alternative options before turning to surgery. Many children who have had the surgery have proven to have improved heart conditions and an improved quality of life.

While the surgery can help many obese children, still some doctors are hesitant to refer young patients for the surgery.

What do YOU think? Should children be able to have bariatric surgery?

posted @ Friday, May 07, 2010 7:21 AM

Print

Comments on this entry:

# re: Should children have weight loss surgery?

Left by Nick at 5/7/2010 8:35 AM
Gravatar
Hmm... I'm not an expert or anything, but I don't believe in surgery unless it's absolutely necessary. For example, a broken bone!

I don't keep up with statistics or anything, but I do have kids and notice others that are obese. I can say that as a parent it is hard to provide kids a healthy lifestyle, but that is the answer to childhood obesity.

I understand that finances, convenience and taste make it hard to do the right thing in terms of giving our kids the right kinds of foods, but ,as parents, it's OUR responsibility. And, I KNOW, our kids don't make it easy for us, but ,again, it's OUR responsibility.

I'll admit that my kids don't eat as healthy as they should. However, they are far from obese. The two things I do to try and keep them straight is control their sugar intake (make sodas a rarity and give them juices with the highest juice content) and MAKE them go outside. I don't have cable or game systems in my house, although I do have Netflix. Every opportunity I can, I take them outside to do something... anything.

My kids are young, my oldest is in kindergarten, so it's pretty easy to control this right now. At the same time, these are their foundational years, so I'm trying to set the tone for the rest of their lives. They all love playing at the playground, going on trail walks, pretty much anything outside. The first thing my oldest asks for when he gets home from school is if he can go outside!

I know I'm speaking from a biased perspective, since my kids aren't obese, but I hope that helps.

Lastly, I would ask that if someone is considering giving their child bariatric surgery, would you be willing to go through the surgery yourself? I'm a member of this sight because, yes, I'm obese and I wouldn't have the surgery myself. In fact, it's not an option. So, I would never consider it for my kids.

# re: Should children have weight loss surgery?

Left by rho84 at 5/7/2010 3:51 PM
Gravatar
The childhood obesity trend is highly alarming! I do not yet have children, but I have kept up on the issue. I feel that where the solution really comes from is education. Most of the cases of childhood obesity comes from non-education of the parents about healthy lifestyles. America as a whole (and unfortunately it is slowly starting to infiltrate more and more developed countries) is poorly educated in making healthy choices. While the surgery is a good last resort it is difficult for children to make the kind of drastic life style changes necessary to accomplish it. Think of everything a child is going through as far as development mentally, physically and emotionally. Now throw on top of that a tremendously intense need to control the diet.

I personally believe that the problem really needs to be addressed before it gets to the point of needing surgery. There needs to be a vast improvement of the way that people are educated in health and fitness - starting in grade school. Parents of obese children should be offered - through the child's doctor - classes on health and fitness. Not waiting until the child is unhealthy in weight, but at the first signs of being over weight. Community centers need to offer a lot more in family fitness courses. Places where whole families can go to learn together how to lead healthy fulfilling lives.

Honestly we need to be so much more proactive than we are as a whole. We need to not let it get to the point of having to let children undergo serious procedures, and major lifestyle upheavals.

# re: Should children have weight loss surgery?

Left by unknown at 5/8/2010 12:40 PM
Gravatar
no what do you think children would feel knowing they have to get a surgery for losing wieght think of that instead

Your comment:



 (will not be displayed)


 
 
 
Please add 7 and 8 and type the answer here:
 

Live Comment Preview: